The Hidden Danger of Remakes and Repeats

Ask anyone over a certain age what the scariest movie ever was, and they will probably tell you “The Exorcist.*”  But if you’re under a certain age, and you see it, you’ll probably raise an eyebrow and wonder if you got the right DVD.

“That’s not so scary,” you think.  At least, that’s what I thought when I saw it.

But then again, if you ask someone over a certain age what the scariest part of “Exorcist” was, they’ll tell you about Linda Blair spinning her head around and spewing pea soup.  Disturbing, I’d imagine, if I wasn’t expecting it.

But I was expecting it, as were you if you’re in my generation.



There’s a hidden danger in making remakes.  That is, they lose their potency because they lose their ability to surprise us.  For a big hit movie, the shocking moments are disseminated through pop culture.  As enjoyable as references are for movies we’ve already seen, they act as spoilers for the generation that follows.  Thanks to Saturday morning cartoons, I knew Darth Vader was Luke Skywalker’s father long before I ever saw “Star Wars.” 

Sometimes, a reference-turned-spoiler is okay.  For example, “The Matrix” has been referenced and parodied a number of times, but only via the slow-motion bullet dodge and crane kick/jump.  Those don’t give away the plot, and I’d imagine if someone grows up watching Matrix references and then sees the Matrix, they’ll recognize the move but probably won’t feel cheated.

Watching “Star Wars,” for the first time, I didn’t feel cheated, per se, but I could tell that something was missing.  What should have been a major moment in the film was just a line I was anticipating.  It didn’t move me.  It was more like Samuel L Jackson’s expression of frustration at having snakes on his plane.  Fun, but not epic.

*Warner Brothers, 1973.

-Tamara Hecht

  • http://www.megamistudios.com Rob

    Funny that you mention that, because last night, I found that one of my favorite films, Labyrinth, actually has a line that dates back to the 40s: http://youtu.be/CBmeOzSzKoY

  • http://profile.typepad.com/genjipress Serdar (Genji Press)

    I actually had an essay somewhere that talked about this phenomenon. Is anyone today surprised by the shower scene in “Psycho”? They’ve seen the homage, the parody, the cheesy joke version of it so many times it’s hard to remember when the original still had any weight.